top of page

Book Review: A Rivalry of Hearts

Writer: Nikki Bulman
Nikki Bulman
Jun 16, 2024
3 min read
“You are beautiful,” he says, voice deep and melodic. “Your words are beautiful. There is no this is more beautiful than that when it comes to you.”

Thank you to Tessonja Odette for my complimentary ARC of A Rivalry of Hearts in exchange for an honest review. This book is available now, and let me tell you—it’s incredible!


Have you ever read a book and wondered what a favorite author would think? I felt like Jane Austen would have enjoyed this one if she were still alive. It’s got period piece elements, a headstrong FMC, a broody-but-misunderstood MMC, witty banter, true love, and a narrative that sheds light on societal norms/taboos. Like Elizabeth Bennet and Mr. Darcy, but with fae and some spice added in. What could be better? 


Some books make us think differently, some stick with us in an informative way, and others are straight up escapism. And all are acceptable (don’t let anyone tell you differently). This book did it all for me, and when I closed the book it almost felt like otherworldly beings could walk among us.


Perhaps it’s the crisp, rich writing that hooked me. Or the humor. Or the LGBTQIA+ representation in an important secondary character (Zane). Or the fact that the title has several meanings. Or the cleverly named sections of the book: “How to Bargain Your Virtue,” “How to Seduce a Stranger,” “How to Romance Your Rival,” and “How to Fall in Love With a Fae.”


“I’ve always maintained that a woman in possession of a vast imagination would want for nothing in life.”

Maybe it’s the fact that both main characters see the world as if it’s a story waiting to be told with people playing characters to tell it. I’m a sucker for when creatives fall for each other—in real life and in fiction. I’ve always thought that artists (of all kinds), musicians, and the like often love deeply. When you’re a creative thinker or creator of any kind, your art form is embedded so deeply in who you are that if you’re lucky enough to find someone who observes the world around them like you do, you respect, appreciate, and admire what’s mirrored there. This is true for Edwina (a writer) and Will (a stage actor) and they bring out the best in each other before they even admit their feelings.


“I can’t force her to be anyone other than who she is. Because I love who she is. I love her.”

You won’t find a detailed commentary on Edwina and William in this review, because you just need to become acquainted with them on the page. Aside from the two of them, my favorite character in this book, by far, is Daphne. At first, we think she’s a minor character, an intern who helps on the book tour the story revolves around. But there is much more to her, and I can’t wait to read her story in the next book. 


Speaking of Daphne, there is an awesome twist with her seelie form that made me audibly gasp. I love when seelie and unseelie fae themes are woven into fantasy tales, and it’s done really well here. Like it’s natural. Most authors—and the folklore that inspires these themes—split seelie fae and unseelie fae into two entities. Odette took a different approach here, wherein all fae have both a seelie form and an unseelie form, and can switch back and forth as they please. It was very cool. 


Check out this book if you’re a Jane Austen fan in need of a break from rereading the classics. Even if period pieces aren’t your vibe,  you’re sure to be swept away reading A Rivalry of Hearts.


This review is also available on Goodreads.

Comments


©2025 by Nikki Bulman @coffeebooksandpluvio

bottom of page