top of page

Book Review: Phantasma

Writer: Nikki Bulman
Nikki Bulman
Oct 14, 2024
2 min read

Updated: Oct 28, 2024

“In all the darkness, in all the loneliness, you have been my own source of light.” 

I thought I’d read dark romance before. I was wrong. 


Holy deliciously fun spice and dark twisty moments, Kaylie Smith.


Between the New Orleans setting, the naming convention for each night of the competition, a very interesting take on apparitions and demons, and true love…I devoured this story in two days, between Kindle and audio.


Speaking of audio, the narrator we all know and love, Laura Horowitz, does an impeccable job. 

“In a different life, in a fair one, I would’ve kept you until my eternal soul withered away to dust,” he vowed to her. 

The reason I don’t always love super spicy books is because they tend to be more spice than anything else. Despite the scorching heat of this world, Smith wove in a solid plot that makes for an enjoyable read. It’s like Hunger Games but adultified, with contestants needing to survive various levels of challenges and “haunts” that pop up in between.


Ophelia Grimm is a necromancer whose world is thrown upside down when her mother dies and her sister enters the Phantasma competition to save them from debt they didn’t know the family had. She wasn’t my favorite FMC, but I respected her for various reasons.


Blackwell is a phantom stuck inside Phantasma as it travels around the world, gaps in his memory leaving him constantly feeling trapped without an obvious way to break the curse that put him there.


Ophelia and Blackwell’s story is intense and lovely at the same time. Not only do they have strong feelings for one another, but they also accept their flaws and make each other feel alive. He goes out of his way to make her believe in herself, and it’s endearing. 

“You don’t need to fix yourself. You’re not broken. But it’s okay to get outside help if it gets too loud.”

The way Smith represents OCD and mental health in this book is incredible. Personally, I don’t have OCD, so I can’t speak to what it’s like. But the way it’s handled here seems to be something that might make folks who do suffer with it feel seen.


The only thing holding me back from five stars here is the Hunger Games similarity, especially with some of the side characters (other contestants).


Phantasma is, simply put, a good book. And very fitting for this spooky season. Pick it up if dark and twisty is your vibe—before book two comes out next year!

Comments


©2025 by Nikki Bulman @coffeebooksandpluvio

bottom of page