Book Review: Potions & Proposals

“Lucinda was kind, polite, and good through and through. It only made Benedict want to corrupt her even more . . . maybe then he would feel worthy of her.”

Thank you to Kate Callaghan for my complimentary ARC of Potions & Proposals in exchange for an honest review.
Lucinda Hawthorne and Benedict Matherson aren’t really enemies-to-lovers . . . they’re more like childhood-friends-to-eventually-become-lovers-after-an-extended-period-of-time-pranking-each-other-like-they’re-still-kids. She’s like Belle buried in books and he’s a self-proclaimed bad boy with a “tainted past” who isn’t actually bad. Who wouldn’t enjoy that mix?!
“He wanted to swallow her whole in his embrace and protect her from anything and anyone who would dare to threaten her loving heart.”
Their relationship, at every stage of this story, was entertaining but sweet. It added to the tension of the book in a clever way, and it was clear to the reader from the very beginning that they were the only ones who didn’t know they were in love.
I really enjoyed the unique magic system in this book. It’s mostly elemental, but not in the way we’re used to in this genre. In a nutshell, witches are “gifted” one element they can control and there aren’t wants, wielding of objects, or hand gestures. They have to carefully brew potions to make other spells happen, including binding people to one another (hint, hint!). Folks without magic are called Magless (like Muggles), and there is even a character who passed away but still gets to interact with the living. In addition to these aspects, though, traditional witchcraft, history (homage to the witch trials), and even Practical Magic are woven in nicely.
“. . . if anything happens to them, or anyone brings them trouble, then no sanctuary in this world or the next can help them.”
Although small-town romances aren’t usually my jam, this story is definitely an exception. Lucinda and Benedict both feel an immense need to protect and serve Foxford no matter what is happening, but in a Gilmore Girls-ish way (not super cheesy). The only exception is that their lives and the outcome of their relationship is a result of an elder council’s meddling.
If you’re like me and counting down the days until fall arrives, this book is for you. It’s a quick, light, cozy read with witchy vibes and just enough witty banter to make you feel like you’re cuddled in a cozy sweater with a spicy candle burning nearby.
Oh, and did I mention there are vampires and other fantastical races, too? This book is currently available on Kindle Unlimited and the paperback will be out on 8.24.
This review is also available on Goodreads.




Comments