top of page

Book Review: The Keyholder of Time

Writer: Nikki Bulman
Nikki Bulman
Jun 23, 2024
3 min read
“But don’t ever, from this moment forward, believe that you aren’t worthy of a place like this. This place isn’t worthy of someone like you.” 

Thank you to Charity F Nelson for my complimentary ARC of The Keyholder of Time in exchange for an honest review.


This book starts out a bit slower as the setting and characters are laid out, but about 100 pages in picks up and Does. Not. Stop. I finished it at 2:30 a.m. (see this Princess Bride gif post for evidence!) and just sat in silence for a bit taking it all in.


Malina is a stubborn, brave, independent FMC who knows her worth but simultaneously doesn’t believe she deserves much. From her braided, Katniss Everdeen-like role of caring for her family to her Cinderella/Ever After upbringing to her big, Claire Fraser heart—she’s very easy to root for.


Some reviewers have said that she feels all over the place and I respectfully disagree. She’s only 18 and she was taken from world only to be thrown into another, after years of being essentially abused by her “family” and living through constant hard times. I felt that Nelson portrayed perspectives and feelings really well and Malina handled the situation better than a typical 18-year-old would.

“I hate you,” I whispered. “I know,” he said, the sound of a smile in his voice.” 

The MMC, Derek, is like a younger, slightly less sarcastic, more YA version of Casteel Da’Neer. If the narrator of the From Blood and Ash audiobooks, Stina Nielsen, were to narrate this series, it would probably feel very similar. The entire first half of the book reminded me of Hawke from that series—a strong protector who seems quiet and a bit sassy but with so much more to him than meets the eye.


What’s interesting is that there are parts of the story where it’s not super clear who Malina is crushing on—Sam, her childhood best friend, Derek, her personal guard, or Loland, her betrothed prince/Derek’s brother. But this isn’t the focal point of the story. The worldbuilding is top-notch; I really enjoyed the map and the way Scottish words, customs, food, and folklore were woven in throughout the story. The familial, financial, and political impacts of the Clan Wars are also so descriptive and embedded, like an additional character.

“I may just have to battle a god again if this is what it takes to get you to kiss me.” “You are impossible.”

There are several delicious plot twists because of the fact that we are learning truths alongside Malina. She belongs to a whole world she wasn’t aware of growing up, so it’s almost like a delayed coming of age story throughout. And the ending . . . — comes back and — is actually — but also the — means — . . . let’s just say Nelson leaves us hanging in a big way.


Finally, this book has quite a few tropes: Slow-burn romance, forced proximity, found family, gods and mortals, a magic system, high-stakes plot, chosen one, arranged marriage, and even a love triangle.


Book two can’t come soon enough! I’m hoping we get to see more romance, more magic, and more of Kirkwood (Malina’s friendship with the gentle giant was one of my favorite elements). Check out The Keyholder of Time if you’re interested in a YA tale with solid worldbuilding, strong characters, humorous banter, and Scottish vibes!


This review is also available on Goodreads.

Comments


©2025 by Nikki Bulman @coffeebooksandpluvio

bottom of page