Book Review: The Spoiler

For all the disbelief you have in yourself, I match it in disbelief that you don’t see what I do.
Thank you to LE Todd for my complimentary ARC of The Spoiler in exchange for an honest review.
This book—which seemed like it would be a straightforward romance but isn’t—made me feel seen and heard. Like there’s a community of movie-loving, period drama fawning, socially anxious, hopeless romantics out there with whom I might belong.
Although brother’s best friend and hockey romance aren’t my typical go-tos, I thoroughly enjoyed this story. The hockey aspects were easy to follow for a non-sportsing person (yes, that’s a technical term) like me. Todd presents the sport as if it’s a character of its own, in a way that’s clear without being overdone or necessitates researching terms just to follow along.
Honestly, her writing is incredible! Her words are eloquent but humanistic, and the way she wove the movie quotes into the narrative without being too cheesy was refreshing. I would LOVE to read a fantasy story by her as I think she would do it so well—major worldbuilding, heartmate, angsty fae/elf/creature vibes. I kept thinking how interesting it would be if Rose, Tristan, Rob, and Drew were set in some sort of historically-adjacent realm with epic battles instead of the early 2000s.
Speaking of fantasy . . .
“Maybe if they were more Lord of the Rings themed, I’d appreciate them.”
This time, he let out a deep laugh and nestled closer to me.
“You know, you’d be buried out by those trash cans if you’d have spoiled LotR for me.”
Is this a hint to readers that maybe LE Todd is considering fantasy?!! Ahh . . .
Anyway. . .
Rose, the FMC of The Spoiler, is relatable and easy to root for. Without giving too much away as her character traits are the building blocks of the story, she suffers from extreme OCD and doesn’t think as highly of herself as she should. Her relationship with Tristan starts off borderline concerning—for a while, I was worried he wouldn’t get a redemption arc (he does) and that Rose would never hear the truth about the movie spoilers he was always throwing at her (she does). I found myself wanting to shake them both by the shoulders several times.
But don’t worry . . . this is a happily-ever-after story (with an amazing ending, by the way!) and it didn’t take long for that frustration to turn into audible “awww”s and fist pumping moments. Their banter is excellent, even when they’re frustrated with one another. His obvious respect and support for her is lovely, as is the tension between them. The spice was a nice surprise!
My one teeny tiny critique is that we didn’t get more of the revenge plot. It’s easy to forget it’s there, although perhaps that was intentional—a way to show that Rose was clearly head-over-heels in love with Tristan instead of truly wishing to get back at him for giving her
a . . . well, you’ll have to read to find out more!
We had tied ourselves together on the most idyllic night I could imagine. You don’t have to live forever, you just have to live. This was the living I needed to do.
One of my favorite aspects of this book was the normalization of mental health and therapy. Not only did Todd do so with Rose’s character when it came to her OCD, but she also subtly called out other characters who would have benefitted from therapy too (including Tristan). Their relationship was reminiscent of The Tearsmith, with neither of them feeling like they deserve the other (which initially comes across as annoyance or even hate).
Definitely give The Spoiler a read if you’re looking for a story that’s easy to get pulled into (I finished it in a day!) with perfectly paced slow-burn, heartfelt moments, and a beautiful love story. It would also serve as a great palette cleanser between lengthier reads or as a good vacation read, without being fluff content. I’ll definitely recommend it to others and read it again soon!
This review is also available on Goodreads.





Comments