How to Nurture the Editor-Author Relationship

Updated: Jul 4, 2023
The hardest part about being an editor isn’t looking for rogue commas and moving paragraphs around. It’s creating and maintaining a positive working relationship with writers. Here are a few tips and tricks to building a fruitful rapport.

The Feedback Sandwich
Using a feedback sandwich injects positivity into editorial review to boost the writer’s confidence while keeping the editor’s ego in check. A feedback sandwich happens when you:
Start with a compliment
Outline areas for improvement
Close with another compliment
This strategy enables the editor to focus on all aspects of the text to avoid the oh-so-easy habit of becoming disgruntled when they see a bad sentence or question a statement that seems untrue.
It also helps the writer feel as though their editor isn’t just red-penning everything they painstakingly put on the page.
Treat the Document Like a Living, Breathing Creature
As an editor, it’s important to remember that the writer spent more time on the document than you. This is true no matter how many rounds of revision you complete through the duration of the project.
Why did the writer use unnecessary semicolons? Maybe stream of consciousness writing is their vibe and a semicolon seemed a natural pausing tool.
Didn’t the writer realize they switched verb tense and personal pronouns a million times? No... they didn’t. A draft is a draft, and they knew they had you to spruce things up.
This writer insists on keeping this sentence in even though I keep advising against it. Ugh! It is their baby, their project after all. Maybe they’re attached to certain phrasing on a deeper level.
Don’t let your own ego get in the way of seeing the drafting process from the writer’s perspective: blood, sweat, and tears.
The Writer is the SME
Just like “the customer is always right,” the writer is always the subject matter expert. Regardless of how much editorial and/or writing experience you have, the writer is always the expert. They wrote what they wrote for a reason and they have a clear understanding of the topic.
Whether it’s character development in a novel, graphs in a technical document, or terminology in a article, always defer to their judgment on the fundamental components of the text.
Collaborative Messaging Is Key
Opening a dialogue with the writer sends a positive message throughout every stage of the project. Some examples include:
Can you shed some light on your strategy here?
I’d like to wrap my head around your approach for this chapter.
If I were the [reader, customer, stakeholder], I might wonder if this paragraph is telling me something I need to know.
Let's workshop this section a bit. When I read it out loud, my first impression is... What are your thoughts on playing with word choice, for example [insert possible alternatives]?
By asking the writer guided questions and displaying a desire to get behind their thought processes, you’re initiating a two-way dance of trust and integrity.
Have a strategy you've found to be effective in your projects? Share it in the comments below!




Comments