top of page

Book Review: Echo of Wings / Echo of Deceit

Writer: Nikki Bulman
Nikki Bulman
Aug 5, 2024
3 min read

Updated: Aug 13, 2024

“I would give you the world, Lillian. Or I’d burn it down for you if that’s what you want. . .”

Thank you to Sophia St. Germain for my complimentary ARC of the first two books in her Echo Series: Echo of Wings and Echo of Deceit.


Have you ever read a book that stays with you so much you think about it everyday after you’ve finished? That’s where I’ve been for the past two weeks!



Life did life things that unfortunately delayed this review, so I’m excited to finally share the thoughts that have been bouncing around in my head. I devoured both books and cannot wait for the third to come out.

“Lillian.” Atlas placed a finger under her chin with surprising gentleness and listed her face to look at him. “Tell me who did this to you.”

Book one, Echo of Wings, is an emotional rollercoaster. The plot twists were plenty, character growth did not disappoint, the plot is fast-paced, and the characters were awesome. In terms of tropes—found family, slowburn romance, and fated mates were done really well here. And although this is technically a fantasy romance series, the majority of book one didn’t feel that way. It leans more toward fantasy with romance is the subplot, which is mostly true in book two as well.


Lillian is a badass FMC by definition, and we get to go on quite the journey with her as she learns about her true identity, the world around her, and even a whole new world as well. In the first half of book one, there are several odes to popular stories: Hunger Games (government-fueled trials, anyone?), A Walk to Remember (Lillian appears to be dying at the start . . .), Gladiator (high-stakes training and again, trials), and even Jane Eyre (check out the end of chapter 32!) all came to mind. 

Finn threw his head back and laughed so loud that several of the other patrons glanced their way. “Golden boy. I love it.”

You probably thought from this quote that Finn is the MMC, right? Nope! Finn is a male character, but not the main one and not a love interest—but he’s just as vital to the story. I won’t elaborate to avoid spoilers, but I will say that Finn is my favorite character.

“In this life, in the next, and whatever comes after that, I’ll love you.”

Book two, Echo of Deceit? Also an emotional rollercoaster! So much happens that I don’t even know where to start without spoiling. Here are some super choppy reactions from my reading notes instead:


  • The tension between Lillian and Kian…wow, and they haven’t even kissed yet. 

  • Valkyries YESSSS.

  • Grete. Hmmm. 

  • ACOTAR (homages but not copying): Volantis, swirly tattoos, learning to use wings, shadowy power (but hers this time), riffing, the MMC giving his mate space and autonomy in political situations (ch. 31). 

  • We get more of Finn’s POV in this one, woo! 

  • Skywielder?!

  • Elya, oh Elya. 

  • Dragons? Dragons. DRAGONS! 

  • THAT ENDING BROKE ME.


In future books, there are a few details I hope we’ll learn more about. For example, how riffing works seems a bit inconsistent at times. And how exactly do bonds operate? Can Kian and Finn hear one another? That said, this story is thoroughly enjoyable and I would recommend the series to anyone who enjoys letting talented writers rip their hearts out only to want more (there might be something wrong with us).


This review is also available on Goodreads.

Comments


©2025 by Nikki Bulman @coffeebooksandpluvio

bottom of page